Teaching Strategies: Integrating AI Thoughtfully
Practical approaches for incorporating AI into your teaching practice
Start Where You Are
Week 1: Personal Exploration
Before asking students to use AI, try it yourself: - Generate quiz questions for your next topic - Create discussion prompts for tutorials - Draft assignment rubrics - Summarise key readings
Document: What worked? What needed fixing? How long did it take?
Week 2: Transparent Modeling
Show students your process: - “I used AI to generate these practice problems, then I…” - “Here’s the original AI output and here’s why I changed it” - “This rubric started with AI, but needed human expertise for…”
Key: Demonstrate critical evaluation, not blind acceptance
Redesigning Assessments for an AI World
From “What” to “How and Why”
Traditional Assessment: “Write a 2000-word essay on marketing strategy”
AI-Aware Assessment Options:
Option A: Process Documentation - Submit AI conversation transcript - Annotate where AI was wrong/limited - Reflection on how human expertise improved output - Final submission shows evolution of thinking
Option B: In-Class Components - AI-generated draft submitted before class - In-class critique and improvement - Peer review of AI use strategies - Live presentation of key insights
Option C: Personal Application - Connect theory to personal experience - Include specific local context - Require primary data collection - Emphasise unique perspective
Practical Classroom Activities
1. AI Error Hunt (15 minutes)
Setup: Generate course content with deliberate errors Activity: Students identify and correct mistakes Learning: Critical evaluation, subject mastery Debrief: Why did AI make these errors?
2. Prompt Engineering Challenge (20 minutes)
Setup: Same question, groups craft different prompts Activity: Compare AI outputs from various prompts Learning: Importance of clear communication Debrief: What made prompts more/less effective?
3. Human vs AI Debate (30 minutes)
Setup: AI generates one side of argument Activity: Students argue opposite position Learning: Critical thinking, argument construction Debrief: What did AI miss about context/nuance?
4. AI Improvement Workshop (25 minutes)
Setup: AI creates initial solution/answer Activity: Groups enhance with human insight Learning: Value of domain expertise Debrief: What uniquely human elements were added?
Setting Clear Expectations
Sample Syllabus Statement
AI Use in This Course
Artificial Intelligence tools are part of professional practice in [field]. In this course:
- You MAY use AI for brainstorming, drafting, and exploration
- You MUST disclose all AI use in assignments
- You MUST verify all AI-generated content
- You CANNOT submit unedited AI content as your own work
Think of AI as a research assistant—helpful but requiring supervision. Your learning comes from evaluating and improving AI output, not from the output itself.
Disclosure Examples
Simple: “AI assisted with initial research”
Detailed: “Used ChatGPT to generate outline structure, refined with course concepts, verified statistics through library databases”
Comprehensive: Appendix with prompts, outputs, and modification log
Managing Different Scenarios
When Students Over-Rely on AI
Signs: Generic responses, missing personal voice, can’t explain work
Strategies: - Require hand-written components - Add oral examinations - Include reflection on process - Focus on application to specific contexts
When Students Fear Using AI
Signs: Anxious about “cheating”, falling behind peers
Strategies: - Model your own AI use - Start with low-stakes activities - Provide clear guidelines - Share success examples
When AI Gives Wrong Information
Opportunity: Teaching moment about verification
Strategies: - Celebrate error detection - Discuss why AI made mistake - Practice fact-checking methods - Emphasise expertise value
Progressive Integration Model
Foundation Level (Weeks 1-4)
- Instructor demonstrates AI use
- Students observe and discuss
- Focus: Understanding capabilities/limitations
Guided Practice (Weeks 5-8)
- Structured AI activities in class
- Clear parameters for use
- Focus: Developing critical evaluation
Independent Application (Weeks 9-12)
- Students choose when/how to use AI
- Justify their decisions
- Focus: Strategic tool selection
Synthesis (Final Weeks)
- Reflect on AI’s role in learning
- Evaluate impact on understanding
- Focus: Meta-cognitive awareness
Quick Implementation Ideas
Monday: Lecture Prep
Use AI to generate example scenarios, verify for accuracy, share process with students
Tuesday: Tutorial Planning
Create discussion questions with AI, add context-specific elements
Wednesday: Assignment Design
Draft rubric with AI, modify for course objectives
Thursday: Student Support
Use AI to create study guides, add personal expertise
Friday: Reflection
Document what worked, adjust for next week
Addressing Common Concerns
“Students will cheat” → Design assessments that require personal insight, process documentation, or live demonstration
“AI undermines learning” → Focus on higher-order thinking: evaluation, synthesis, creation
“I don’t understand AI” → Start small, learn alongside students, share your journey
“It’s not fair if some students use AI” → Make AI use transparent and optional, provide alternatives
Assessment Rubric Adaptation
Traditional Criteria → AI-Era Criteria
Knowledge Display → Knowledge Application - Can recite facts → Can verify AI facts - Memorised content → Contextualised understanding
Writing Quality → Thinking Quality - Grammar/spelling → Argument construction - Word count → Idea development
Research Skills → Evaluation Skills - Found sources → Assessed AI sources - Citation accuracy → Information verification
Originality → Synthesis - Unique phrasing → Unique connections - No plagiarism → Acknowledged AI use
Red Flags vs Green Flags
🚩 Red Flags (Need Intervention)
- Cannot explain their work
- Inconsistent voice/knowledge level
- Missing assignment-specific requirements
- No personal connection to content
🟢 Green Flags (Good Practice)
- Clear about AI’s role
- Shows iteration and improvement
- Demonstrates critical thinking
- Adds personal/local context
Resources for Further Development
Essential Reading
- Your institution’s AI policy
- Discipline-specific AI guidelines
- Student feedback on AI use
Try This Week
- Generate one lecture example with AI
- Share the process with students
- Ask students about their AI use
- Document one success or failure
Build Community
- Share experiences with colleagues
- Create discipline-specific prompt library
- Develop shared assessment strategies
Final Reminders
✓ You don’t need to be an AI expert — You need to be a learning expert
✓ Perfect is the enemy of good — Small experiments are valuable
✓ Students are already using AI — Better to guide than ignore
✓ Your expertise matters more, not less — AI makes human judgment crucial
✓ Focus on learning outcomes — Tools change, objectives remain
Resources & References
- (Heaven, W. (2023, April 6). ChatGPT is going to change education, not destroy it. MIT Technology Review. Retrieved September 4 2025, from https://www.technologyreview.com/2023/04/06/1070216/chatgpt-is-going-to-change-education-not-destroy-it)[https://www.technologyreview.com/2023/04/06/1071059/chatgpt-change-not-destroy-education-openai/]
- (Sabzalieva, E., & Valentini, A. (2023). ChatGPT and artificial intelligence in higher education: Quick start guide. UNESCO International Institute for Higher Education in Latin America and the Caribbean (IESALC). https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000385146)[https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000385146]
- (Russell Group. (2023). Russell Group principles on the use of generative AI tools in education. Russell Group. Retrieved September 4 2025, from https://www.russellgroup.ac.uk/policy/policy-briefings/principles-use-generative-ai-tools-education)[https://www.russellgroup.ac.uk/policy/policy-briefings/principles-use-generative-ai-tools-education]
- TEQSA on Generative AI
Questions? Contact: michael.borck@curtin.edu.au
Version 1.0 - September 2025 | Part of the AI in Curriculum initiative
AI Acknowledgement: AI tools were used in the initial drafting and development of this document. All content has been reviewed, refined, and validated through human expertise and professional judgment.