Moving Past AI Shame: A Discussion Guide
Practical resources for navigating AI use in academic settings
Understanding AI Shame - Two Perspectives
Academic Perspective: “AI Shaming in Academia”
Summary of Louis Jere’s article on AI stigma in higher education
Definition: AI shaming is the stigma or criticism directed at academics who use AI tools, seen as undermining the ideal that scholarship should be entirely “human intellect-driven.”
Real Examples from Academia: - Researchers rejected from journals after editors discovered AI use for brainstorming - Junior academics accused of cheating for using AI to polish writing - Faculty hiding their AI use from tenure committees
Types of AI Shamers Identified: - Traditionalists – Value established methods, resist change - Technophobes – Fear technology and AI generally - Elitists – See AI as threat to status or expertise - Luddites – Fear disruption to academic livelihoods - Misunderstanders – Don’t grasp AI capabilities, default to sci-fi fears
Consequences of AI Shaming: - Stifles innovation in research methods - Wastes effort on repetitive tasks - Creates underground usage without best practices - Disadvantages early-career researchers
The Bold Transparency Approach: Louis Jere openly used ChatGPT while writing about AI shaming, advocating for normalising disclosure as a path forward.
Workplace Perspective: Fortune/Canva Study (2025)
How AI shame manifests in professional settings
Key Findings: - 70% of knowledge workers use AI weekly - 63% fear being seen as incompetent or lazy - Most hide their AI use from colleagues - Creates “readiness gap” between expectation and support
The Pattern Across Sectors: Both academia and industry show similar patterns of shame, secrecy, and missed opportunities for collaborative learning.
Reframing Our Relationship with AI
From Shame to Partnership
Traditional View: “Real scholarship is purely human intellect” Alternative View: “Scholarship is human intellect directing appropriate tools”
Traditional View: “Using AI is cheating” Alternative View: “Using AI without disclosure or understanding is problematic”
Traditional View: “AI threatens academic integrity” Alternative View: “Hidden AI use threatens integrity; transparent use enhances it”
Traditional View: “AI will replace academics” Alternative View: “AI augments academic capabilities for those who master it”
Questions for Reflection
Rather than prescribing how to think, consider: - What tools do you already use that were once controversial? (calculators, spell-check, citation managers) - How is AI different from or similar to these tools? - What would responsible, transparent AI use look like in your discipline? - How might AI free you to focus on higher-level academic work?
Moving Forward: A Collaboration Mindset
Proposed Actions (from the literature)
Individual Level: - Experiment with one small task - Document and share your process - Practice transparent disclosure - Shift from “human vs. machine” to “human + machine”
Department Level: - Create safe spaces for AI experimentation - Share both successes and failures - Develop discipline-specific guidelines - Educate about actual AI capabilities (vs. sci-fi myths)
Institutional Level: - Establish clear, supportive policies - Provide training and resources - Recognise AI literacy as professional development - Support “post-digital academic writing” practices
Key Message from Research
Both academic and industry research conclude: AI should be seen as an augmenting partner, not a replacement. Overcoming shame requires honesty about use, curiosity about possibilities, and willingness to evolve practices.
Resources & References
- (McNealis, R. Shame in the machine: affective accountability and the ethics of AI. AI & Soc (2025). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-025-02472-x)[https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00146-025-02472-x]
- (Giray L. (2024). AI Shaming: The Silent Stigma among Academic Writers and Researchers. Annals of biomedical engineering, 52(9), 2319–2324. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10439-024-03582-1)[https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38977530/]
- (Sabzalieva, E., & Valentini, A. (2023). ChatGPT and artificial intelligence in higher education: Quick start guide. UNESCO International Institute for Higher Education in Latin America and the Caribbean (IESALC). https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000385146)[https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000385146]
- (WalkMe. (2025, August 27). Employees left behind in workplace AI boom, new WalkMe survey finds - WalkMe - Digital adoption Platform. WalkMe - Digital Adoption Platform. https://www.walkme.com/news-releases/employees-left-behind-in-workplace-ai-boom-new-walkme-survey-finds/?tabId=company-news)[https://www.walkme.com/news-releases/employees-left-behind-in-workplace-ai-boom-new-walkme-survey-finds/?tabId=company-news]
- (Russell Group. (2023). Russell Group principles on the use of generative AI tools in education. Russell Group. Retrieved September 4 2025, from https://www.russellgroup.ac.uk/policy/policy-briefings/principles-use-generative-ai-tools-education)[https://www.russellgroup.ac.uk/policy/policy-briefings/principles-use-generative-ai-tools-education]
- (Lichtenberg, N. (2025, August 29). “AI shame” is running rampant in the corporate sector—and C-suite leaders are most worried about getting caught, survey says. Fortune. https://fortune.com/2025/08/29/what-is-ai-shame-readiness-gap-training-artificial-intelligence/)[https://fortune.com/2025/08/29/what-is-ai-shame-readiness-gap-training-artificial-intelligence/]
- Canva Workplace Study on AI Adoption (2025)
- TEQSA on Generative AI
Support: - Contact: michael.borck@curtin.edu.au - Companion website: [to be added] - Prompt library: [to be added]
Questions? Contact: michael.borck@curtin.edu.au Version 3.0 - September 2025
Drawing on both academic and industry research on AI shame
AI Acknowledgement: AI tools were used in the initial drafting and development of this document. All content has been reviewed, refined, and validated through human expertise and professional judgment.